Intelligence is open

Smart city versus open city


  • Rafael Lemieszek Pinheiro Independent researcher




Open data, Smart city, Smart technology, Collaborative platforms


In this paper we explore the impacts, current and potential, that new technologies have on city planning and management, comparing the different ways in which those impacts can be harnessed for either the public good, for private profit or for a mixture of both. We argue that smart technologies do not necessarily yield a positive social product, and that the openness of information (in its different levels) plays an important part in maximizing the social product of new technologies applied to urban space. In the first part, we briefly discuss urban complexity and how technology can be used to make cities readable and actionable upon. In the second part, we analyse three technological (“smart”) initiatives related to urban planning; Waze, Uber and OpenStreetMap, analysing the different processes by which information can be turned into use-value (and from there into exchange value). In the third part, we try to understand the economic process by which information is turned into capital through its restriction. We conclude by analysing the potential conflicts between the common good and the turning of information into capital, exploring some of the ways in which open data might be important in the process of making better cities.





Research article


Appelberg, S. (2014, March 28). Lawsuit: Waze Owes ‘Open-source’ Programmers $150 Million. Haaretz. Retrieved September 30, 2015, from

Bialik, C., Flowers, A., Fischer-Baum, R., & Mehta, D. (2015). Uber Is Serving New York’s Outer Boroughs More Than Taxis Are. FiveThirtyEight. Retrieved September 30, 2015, from

Biddle, S. (2015). Here Are the Internal Documents that Prove Uber Is a Money Loser. Gawker.

Retrieved September 30, 2015, from

Broad, E. (2015). Closed, shared, open data: what’s in a name? Open Data Institute. Retrieved

September 19, 2015, from Coase, R. H. (1960). The Problem of Social Cost. Chicago: University of Chicago Law School.

Coast, S. (2014, August 9) For The Love of Open Mapping Data/Interviewer: F. Lardinois. Techcrunch.

Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Cohan, P. (2013, 11/6/2013). Four Reasons Google Bought Waze. Forbes. Retrieved September 18, 2015, from

Dediu, H. (2012). How much do maps cost and what are they worth? Asymco. Retrieved September 18, 2015, from

Dorn, H., Törnros, T., & Zipf, A. (2015). Quality Evaluation of VGI Using Authoritative Data—A Comparison with Land Use Data in Southern Germany. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 4(3), 1657-1671.

Excellence, A. C. f. E. (2008). Above and Beyond: The Environmental and Social Contributions of America’s Highway Programs. Washington: American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials.

Fagin, D. (2014, 03/02/2014). Life as an Uber Driver: It’s Just Not Fare. Huffington Post. Retrieved September 28, 2015, from

Fox, J. (2015, 29/06/2015). Uber Is Lobbying for All of Us. Bloomberg View. Retrieved September 28, 2015, from

Greenfield, A. (2013). Against the smart city (The city is here for you to use). Helsinki: Do projects. Haklay, M. (2010). How good is volunteered geographical information? A comparative study of OpenStreetMap and Ordnance Survey datasets. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 37(2010), 682-703. doi:10.1068/b35097

Hall, J. V., & Krueger, A. B. (2015). An Analysis of the Labor Market for Uber’s Driver-Partners in the United States. Princeton: Princeton University. Retrieved September 28, 2015, from 5/587.pdf

Helderman, R. S. (2014, 13/12/2014). Uber pressures regulators by mobilizing riders and hiring vast lobbying network. The Washington Post. Retrieved September 28, 2015, from

Jacobs, J. (1969). The Economy of Cities. New York: Random House.

Jain, T. R. O., V. K. (2010). Principles of Economics. New Delhi: VK Publications.

Kokalitcheva, K. (2015, 24/08/2015). Uber and Lyft are spending big bucks on lobbying in California. Fortune. Retrieved September 21, 2015, from 08/24/uber-and-lyft-are-spending-big-bucks-on-lobbying-in-california/

Komanoff, C. (2015). The BTA (Balanced Transportation Analyzer). Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Lipsey, R. G., & Harbury, C. (1992). First Principles of Economics: Oxford University Press. Litman, T. (2013). Understanding transport demands and elasticities. How prices and other factors affect travel behavior. (Victoria Transport Policy Institute: Litman) Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Machado, A. (2013, 24/7/2013). Prefeitura começa a usar Waze no Centro de Operações Rio. O Globo. Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

MacMillan, D., & Demos, T. (2015, 31/07/2015). Uber Valued at More Than $50 Billion. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved September 22, 2015, from

Magalhães, A. (2013). O direito das favelas. Rio de Janeiro: Letra Capital.

Marx, K. (1889). Capital: A Critical Analysis of Capitalist Production (S. Moore & E. B. Aveling, Trans.). London: F. Engels Ed.

Mathew, B. (2005). Taxi!: Cabs and Capitalism in New York City. New York: ILR Press.

Navteq. (2007). Navteq Annual Report 2006. Retrieved September 18, 2015, from

Neis, P., & Zielstra, D. (2014). Recent developments and future trends in volunteered geographic information research: The case of OpenStreetMap. Future Internet, 6(1), 76-106.

Neis, P., Zielstra, D., & Zipf, A. (2011). The street network evolution of crowdsourced maps: OpenStreetMap in Germany 2007–2011. Future Internet, 4(1), 1-21.

Orwell, G. (1945). As I Please. Liverpool: Nonpareil.

Palen, L., Soden, R., Anderson, T. J., & Barrenechea, M. (2015). Success & Scale in a Data-Producing Organization: The Socio-Technical Evolution of OpenStreetMap in Response to Humanitarian Events. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 33rd Annual ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems.

Roberts, B. K. (2015, 4/5/2015). Will traffic NIMBYs ruin Waze? Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 21, 2015, from

Rom, I. (2014, 10/12/2014). The Source: the drivers that vanished from Waze success map. Channel 10 News. Retrieved September 23, 2015, from

Rose, J. M., & Hensher, D. A. (2014). Demand for taxi services: new elasticity evidence. Transportation, 41(4), 717-743.

Sandelin, B., Trautwein, H.-M., & Wundrak, R. (2014). A Short History of Economic Thought. London: Routledge.

Schaller, B. (1999). Elasticities for taxicab fares and service availability. Transportation. 26: 283-297.

Shrank, D., Eisele, B., Lomax, T., & Bak, J. (2015). 2015 Urban Mobility Scorecard. Retrieved September 23, 2015, from

Sterling, B. (2014). Smart City States [Video]. Retrieved September 12, 2015, from

Tepper, F. (2015, 22/07/2015). Uber Releases Hourly Ride Numbers In New York City To Fight De Blasio. Techcrunch. Retrieved September 23, 2015, from

The Economist (2015, August 15). A tale of two cities. The Economist. Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Thompson, E. P. (2002). The Making of the English Working Class. London: Penguin.

TomTom. (2010). Annual Report 2009. Retrieved September 18, 2015, from

TomTom. (2015). Annual Report 2014. Retrieved September 18, 2015, from

Townsend, A. M. (2013). Smart Cities: Big Data, Civic Hackers, and the Quest for a New Utopia. New York:W. W. Norton.

Tregarthen, T. D., & Rittenberg, L. (2000). Economics (2nd ed.). New York: Worth Publishers.

Uber. (2015a). Rides By Hour Since June (report). Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Uber. (2015b). Sign Up To Drive With Uber - Earn Cash With Your Car. Retrieved September 17, 2015, from

Van Gelder, L. (1996, 11/05/1996). Medallion Limits Stem From the 30’s. The New York Times. Retrieved September 16, 2015, from 11/nyregion/medallion-limits-stem-from-the-30-s.html

von Thünen, J. H. (1826). Der isolirte Staat in Beziehung auf Landwirtschaft und Nationalökonomie: Wirtschaft & Finan.

Zhang, S., & Shih, G. (2015, 21/08/2015). Uber seen reaching $10.8 billion in bookings in 2015: fundraising presentation. Reuters. Retrieved September 16, 2015, from

Zielstra, D. H., Hartwig. (2012). Using Free and Proprietary Data to Compare Shortest-Path Lengthsfor Effective Pedestrian Routing in Street Networks. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2299, 41-47. doi:10.3141/2299-05